Physician Assisted Suicide Case study :: essays research papers

Diane A Case of Physician Assisted SuicideDiane was a patient of Dr. Timothy flagroot, who was diagnosed with corking myelomonocytic leukemia. Diane overcame alcoholism and had vaginal cancer in her youth. She had been under his care for a period of 8 years, during which an intimate doctor-patient bond had been established. It was Dr. Quills observation that she was an unbelievably clear, at times brutally honest, thinker and communicator. This observation became especially cogent after Diane heard of her diagnosis. Dr. Quill inform her of the diagnosis, and of the possible sermons. This series of treatments entailed multiple chemotherapy sessions, followed by a bone marrow transplant, accompanied by an array of ancillary treatments. At the end of this series of treatments, the survival rate was 25%, and it was further complicate in Dianes case by the absence of a closely matched bone-marrow donor. Diane chose not to receive treatment, desiring to spend whatever time she had l eft outside of the hospital. Dr. Quill met with her several times to ensure that she didnt change her mind, and he had Diane meet with a psychologist with whom she had met before. Then Diane complicated the case by informing Dr. Quill that she be able to control the time of her death, avoiding the loss of dignity and discomfort which would precede her death. Dr. Quinn informed her of the Hemlock Society, and shortly afterwards, Diane called Dr. Quinn with a request for barbiturates, complaining of insomnia. Dr. Quinn gave her the prescription and informed her how to use them to sleep, and the amount necessary to commit suicide. Diane called all of her friends to say goodbye, including Dr. Quinn, and took her life two days after they met.This is a fascinating case because it presents the distinction surrounded by a patients right to refuse treatment and a physicians assistance with suicide. Legally, Diane possessed the right to refuse treatment, but she would curb faced a debilitat ing, painful death, so the issue of treatment would be a moot point. It would be moot in the sense that Diane seemed to refuse treatment because the odds were low, even if she survived she would spend significant periods of time in the hospital and in pain, and if she didnt survive she would spend her last days in the hospital. If Diane were to scarce refuse treatment and nothing else (as the law prescribes) than she would not have been able to avoid the death which she so dearly wanted to avoid.